tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post3762624961861823715..comments2024-03-29T10:33:48.724+05:30Comments on Faith Revisited: Meat eating and animal killing in valmiki ramayanOneGod-OneWehttp://www.blogger.com/profile/01622922302145752321noreply@blogger.comBlogger42125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-21973009804874322502021-05-28T14:23:55.633+05:302021-05-28T14:23:55.633+05:30माँस और मांस संस्कृत के दो भिन्न शब्द हैं|
माँस =...माँस और मांस संस्कृत के दो भिन्न शब्द हैं|<br /><br />माँस = माम् + सम = myself(my body) + similar to.<br /><br />मांस = मान् + सम = measuring(unit standard) + equivalent to.<br /><br />So, don't fight and moot over the misinterpretation and printing mistakes and blunders. Please don't defend the foreign sophistry based arguments.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-63797595719521298502021-05-22T17:32:26.143+05:302021-05-22T17:32:26.143+05:30Jai Shri Ram. Very well researched article and a g...Jai Shri Ram. Very well researched article and a good way to expose this vegetarian propaganda against us Hindus <br /><br />More than 70% Hindus eat meat. Our scriptures don't say anything against meat eating. Ayurveda recommends different type of meat based on our body type <br /><br />It's these organisations like Iskcon and others who have their own vested interests and promote vegetarianism among Hindus to divide us further Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-49623183227743762412020-06-05T22:32:40.711+05:302020-06-05T22:32:40.711+05:30According to many Islamic scholars ISLAM is the on...According to many Islamic scholars ISLAM is the only religion in the world and it glorifies establishing ISLAM worlwide by killing other religions. Then what moral right you have to speak on Hindus. Also for your information Asuras or Danavas ate animal flesh. Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-17323692606138555332020-05-20T12:59:09.919+05:302020-05-20T12:59:09.919+05:30hii, friend great article, proud of u, u r true In...hii, friend great article, proud of u, u r true Indian and intelligent human being, because humans are not plant eaters. In fact we are the only animal that cook our food.<br /><br />Animal like cow, buffalo, deer , goats are ruminants that is they have four stomach that is they have to first ingest the food ferment it inside the stomach then send the food back to mouth an then again ingest it.<br /><br />Human can't digest plant based foods unless we cook it at high temperature in the presence of salt and ghee only after treating plant this way or say cooking it this way we can digest it.<br /><br />The only reason that India has remain a slave country from last 1000 years is because we have stopped eating meat. Even today we are just population to serve the western nation with manpower, if we start eating meat atleast 3 a week we can again become global superpower.<br /><br />Just one question what did tulsi das wrote Sumit Bhattacharyahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06990981939752280067noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-90062484664607938782020-05-05T15:15:09.232+05:302020-05-05T15:15:09.232+05:30Very nice and eye opening article for blind Hindus...Very nice and eye opening article for blind Hindus. importantly one can believe your points because you have explained with comparing both true meaning of Sanskrit with misguiding false meaning done by so called fake Hindu propogadists who are backed up by political propogandists.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03928010416507693154noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-41148844726581180982020-04-11T02:01:43.683+05:302020-04-11T02:01:43.683+05:30Do You Know Sanskirit?
BTW,How Many Hindus Knows S...Do You Know Sanskirit?<br />BTW,How Many Hindus Knows Sanskirit In India? MythBusterhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05548615485297152204noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-49681177802429258562020-04-11T01:59:02.033+05:302020-04-11T01:59:02.033+05:30Good Spin ...Good Spin ...MythBusterhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05548615485297152204noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-90941498152283921202019-08-28T06:55:09.800+05:302019-08-28T06:55:09.800+05:30have you reviwed islam
have you reviwed islam<br />Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13565623224665277241noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-29698328238027909582019-08-15T11:28:58.331+05:302019-08-15T11:28:58.331+05:30Lolzz Kurshid Imam is Biggot who thinks Homosexual...Lolzz Kurshid Imam is Biggot who thinks Homosexuality is wrong just because it is written in Quran name book.Testhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09124870387520311741noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-12831304606827000172019-03-27T00:56:35.175+05:302019-03-27T00:56:35.175+05:30Dear brother did you know that Sri ram married sit...Dear brother did you know that Sri ram married sita devi at what age ? Sita Devi age at marriage is only 6 years.this is also mention in original Ramayana @ valmiki ramayana.please check.<br />Xyzhttp://xyznoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-23867623658193539432018-09-29T16:41:11.341+05:302018-09-29T16:41:11.341+05:30abdul wahid...you are right...everything should be...abdul wahid...you are right...everything should be read in the context....so better teach this to zakir naik and to this cynnical blog writer....who has hardly any knowledge on Sanskrit, telling that mamsa mean meat and amisha mean non-veg etc. The problem with you islamsists is that you guys only understand the language of hatred. Look at yourself how you are spreading lies...is ther anything like this in the Vedas or the Gita..can you cite the shloka....no ofcourse no...because you islamists are a bunch of stupid notorious goons who only understand the language of lies, deceit, falsehood, and hatred. Regarding quran,,,it is full of verses promoting, sex slavery, slavery, killing of non-muslims etc etc in all context....Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-71084788946594564502018-09-27T18:41:50.539+05:302018-09-27T18:41:50.539+05:30Agoris are a deserted cult..they dont represent Hi...Agoris are a deserted cult..they dont represent Hinduism or Hindu chore dcotrine....Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-53981587601212843352018-05-08T00:37:43.337+05:302018-05-08T00:37:43.337+05:30dear brother salam!
The Holy Qur'an and the ot...dear brother salam!<br />The Holy Qur'an and the other all holy books prohibit meat. Please read and think twice the holy verses again.Ra Zennoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-84155401616249547232018-03-02T13:31:33.771+05:302018-03-02T13:31:33.771+05:30Valmiki Ramayana, the original narration of Ramaya...Valmiki Ramayana, the original narration of Ramayana, has a total of 537 chapters, and over 24,000 verses, arranged into six kandas, or books. There are only two references to meat, and over a hundred references to a vegetarian diet. The Ayodhya kanda has 119 chapters. Chapter 20 describes Mother Kaushalya’s grievous lamentation on hearing from her son Rama that He has been banished to the forest. Rama tells her in verse 29, “I shall live in a solitary forest like a sage for fourteen years, avoiding meat and living with roots, fruits and honey.” Can we validly infer from this that Lord Rama ate meat while in Ayodhya, and now He promises to avoid it in the forest? The exact words used are hitva amisam. Amisam refers to “meat” and hitva refers to “disregarding” or “with the exception of” (Monnier Williams dictionary). <br /><br />Traditionally, in Vedic culture, when a son leaves home to go to distant lands, he reassures his parents that he would abide by strict moral codes and never deviate from the religious principles. Imagine a student promising his parents when going to stay in the hostel, “I won’t drink alcohol while in the hostel.” Does this mean that he is drinking it while at home? Obviously not. Similarly it’s in this mood that Lord Rama assures His mother that He wouldn’t stoop low. In Chapter 26, Lord Rama tells Mother Sita of His decision to go to the forest and instructs her to stay in Ayodhya. There is no reference to any eating meat or otherwise in any verse of this chapter. Moreover in almost all the verses of chapter 94, Lord Rama glorifies the various fruits, trees, and flowers at the forest of Citrakuta, with absolutely no reference to any meat-eating whatsoever.<br /><br />Did Mother Sita ask Lord Rama to kill the deer? In the third book, Aranya-kanda, Chapter 43, Mother Sita spots the golden deer and asks Lord Rama to fetch it. She asks, “O nobleman’s son, that delightful deer is stealing My heart. O dextrous one, bring it round; it will be our plaything.” [3-43-10]. In the next eight verses She rejoices at the prospect of taking the deer back to Ayodhya where the animal will delight all the palace residents. She clarifies that if the deer is to be killed at all (Lakshmana had earlier warned it to be a demon), then They could use the deerskin as a seat. (3-43-19, 20). The forest dwelling sages used kusa grass and deerskin as seats during the earlier ages when flora and fauna was in abundance. Here again there is not even a hint that Lord Rama or Sita wanted to eat the flesh of the golden deer. In the chapter 36 of Sundara-kanda, Hanuman assures Mother Sita that Lord Rama would cross over the ocean and defeat Ravana. He reveals that although Lord Rama is in great sorrow of separation from Mother Sita, He hasn’t fallen down to intoxicants or meat eating (verse 41).<br /><br />Mamsa has another meaning, than meat the flesh of a fruit. In the South Indian temple town of Sri Rangam, when priests offer mango to Lord Ranganatha, they chant the prayer, iti amra mamsa khanda samarpayami: “I offer mango-mamsa (mango flesh) for the Lord to eat.” Thus even if there are occasional references to mamsa, we should know they refer to fruit pulp.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13976221223667143518noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-63455435239633398822017-09-09T15:36:03.193+05:302017-09-09T15:36:03.193+05:30What you have (mis)quoted (Quran 9:5,9:14) are a w...What you have (mis)quoted (Quran 9:5,9:14) are a war cry to boost the morale of the warriors in the battlefield. If you want to know the true meaning of that verse, go to the previous verses and the ones come after. You can't just take words out of context. Do you know the fact that similar, if not the same verses are existing in your own scriptures? I found tons of such verses of the same nature in Hindu scripture. Here are few for your kind perusal.<br /><br /> "Kill the opponents of Vedas" - Atharva Veda: 20-93-12. "(O King!) you reach everyone who tells the evil (tells against Vedas) and kill Him - Atharva Veda::20-74-7. "O Indra ! Kill the sinful ass (a person who mocks Vedas)" - Atharva Veda: 20-74-5 . "Wage the religious war" - Gita: 2:32:34<br /><br />"Slay each reviler and destroy him who in secret injures us" - Atharva Veda: 20-74-7. "Destroy this ass, O Indra, who in tones discordant brays to thee" - Atharva Veda: 20-74-7. "Display thy bounty.Thunderer, Drive off the enemies of prayer. Crush with thy foot the niggard churls who bring no gifts. - Atharva Veda: 29-93-1&2.Abdul Wahid S.https://www.blogger.com/profile/02227491085073074015noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-20731351207668803432017-09-09T14:45:13.174+05:302017-09-09T14:45:13.174+05:30According to both Ramayana and Ramcharitmanas gods...According to both Ramayana and Ramcharitmanas gods and rishis killed animals for their skins either for seating or for dress. If these annimals can be killed for hides what is wrong in killing them for food?Abdul Wahid S.https://www.blogger.com/profile/02227491085073074015noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-44932608122812230672017-09-09T14:34:31.793+05:302017-09-09T14:34:31.793+05:30Aghoris are doing that.Aghoris are doing that.Abdul Wahid S.https://www.blogger.com/profile/02227491085073074015noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-1212584567740020142017-08-01T13:06:48.332+05:302017-08-01T13:06:48.332+05:30movvamadhuri@yahoo.commovvamadhuri@yahoo.comSaatyaki S / o Seshendra Sharmahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00887279200790561271noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-24820704123130859502017-07-15T17:34:52.979+05:302017-07-15T17:34:52.979+05:30Dear Priyankar, don't demean the position of G...Dear Priyankar, don't demean the position of God and say you are proud to be Hindu... <br /><br />Dear Khurshid, As regards interpretation of Sanskrit, pls understand that each word in Sanskrit has many meanings and then there is interpretation in context. To properly understand these things require many years (atleast 12 years) of rigorous study under guidance of an expert teacher.<br /><br />Before commenting in the garb of secularism, a genuine process needs to be followed and then you can enter the spirit and understanding of the texts.<br /><br />While the word Amish also mean high level of comforts, Mamsa also means fruit pulp. <br /><br />So lets no hurry to brand a selfless translator as misleader. spend more time in understanding the scripture and the glories of Lord Rama.<br /><br />May Lord Rama bless you with right consciousness.<br /> Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/16247858799883082657noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-72494701648020390382017-04-11T04:36:58.370+05:302017-04-11T04:36:58.370+05:30Naveen Raghuvanshi " Imagine a student promis...Naveen Raghuvanshi " Imagine a student promising his parents when going to stay in the hostel, “I won’t drink alcohol while in the hostel.” Does this mean that he is drinking it while at home? Obviously not. Similarly it’s in this mood that Lord Rama assures His mother that He wouldn’t stoop low."....Does it imply that there were people eating meat at that time? and Rama promises not join them?<br />I still cant understand how they got deer skins and tiger skins without killing them?.....Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-62374627548613972082017-02-27T11:49:27.552+05:302017-02-27T11:49:27.552+05:30While stabilizing the original text of Ramayana, h...While stabilizing the original text of Ramayana, historians surmised that portions of two Books [Kaandas], namely Book I, Bala Kaanda and Book VII, Uttara Ramayana (not listed above) are later additions - "The first and the last Books of the Ramayana are later additions. The bulk, consisting of Books II--VI, represents Rama as an ideal hero. In Books I and VII, however Rama is made an avatara or incarnation of Vishnu, and the epic poem is transformed into a Vaishnava text. The reference to the Greeks, Parthians, and Sakas show that these Books cannot be earlier than the second century B.C......"[ The cultural Heritage of India, Vol. IV, The Religions, The Ramakrishna Mission, Institute of Culture ].reference-http://www.valmikiramayan.net/Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-80075174731409807042016-11-29T14:14:14.806+05:302016-11-29T14:14:14.806+05:30Dear Khurshid Imam Saheb,
You have done your lot ...Dear Khurshid Imam Saheb,<br /><br />You have done your lot of research work. However the recent cancer researches have proved that meat eating is one of the major cause of Cancer, Obesity, Diabetes as every byproduct of meat is carcinogenic.<br /><br />You have quoted Holy Quran, it is excellent. <br />Dead meat, blood, flesh of swine and any food on which name other than God has been pronounced - is prohibited. Quran 5:3<br /><br />Learned scholar Dr.Zakir Naik Tells one must follow the scriptures to understand the religion, He is absolutely right and 100 marks for him.. Kindly note the following verses from Holy Quran and Hadith. If anyone is not a Muslim( Jews, Christians, Buddhists, Hindus, Jains, Sikhs) does he/She has no right to live. The Jihadis are exactly doing things written in Quran. Are the teachings appropriate logically from Humanistic point of view?<br /><br /> And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful. ( Quran 9.5)<br /> <br />Fight them; Allah will punish them by your hands and will disgrace them and give you victory over them and satisfy the breasts of a believing people. ( Quran 9.14) <br /><br />The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of Allah "; and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of Allah ." That is their statement from their mouths; they imitate the saying of those who disbelieved [before them]. May Allah destroy them; how are they deluded? ( Quran 9.30)<br /> <br />The Verse:--"You (true Muslims) are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind." means, the best of peoples for the people, as you bring them with chains on their necks till they embrace Islam. Sahih al-Bukhari Book 60 Hadith 80 <br /><br />Muslims often accuse other religions of idolatry. Yet Muslims bow down to a pagan temple called the "Kaaba" (which is what the pagans of Arabia did before the rise of Islam); they take a pilgrimage to the Kaaba (which is what the pagans of Arabia did before the rise of Islam); they walk circles around the Kaaba (which is what the pagans of Arabia did before the rise of Islam); and they kiss the black stone embedded in the corner of the Kaaba (which is what the pagans of Arabia did before the rise of Islam). Should our Muslim friends be accusing anyone of idolatry? Glass houses!<br /><br />Surahs and Ayats. Do you agree with it Mr Khurshid?<br /><br />Scholars and followers of Noble Islam kindly comment with logical interpretation and proof .<br /><br />Biswa Prakashnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-12255997859666750832016-09-02T01:43:35.628+05:302016-09-02T01:43:35.628+05:30You need to learn sanskrit. Some words have many m...You need to learn sanskrit. Some words have many meanings and you have to pick the right one depending on the situation.Milin Patelhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11903369568792692109noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-53867489207946500912016-07-27T10:59:17.066+05:302016-07-27T10:59:17.066+05:30A very good article.Thank you for sharing. food wa...A very good article.Thank you for sharing. food was always a debate in religions; in Indian and middle-eastern religions as well. very few hindus, unlike me, try to understand that any religion made up of certain idea or schools (fitna/sampradaya) and different schools become dominant or recessive in certain times. Starting from Vedic times the central ritual was homa, where yajman(arya) use to sacrifice food to God (all sorts of food from fruits, flowers, liquor to meat)as gratitude. the emergence of Buddhism (1st millienium) had deep impact on hinduism and it become tyaga oriented (ascetic) from bhoga oriented (family bound). So animal sacrifices and meat-eating start becoming taboo. the effect also comes in religious scriptures; basically the most glorified divine book "ramayana", the meat-eating Rama-Sita-Lakshmana start being fruit-eating (as it fits change in culture). If someone observantly see, with change in culture in last 100 years, Ramayana has changed a lot. the animations, which are generally accepted as caricature, but positively accepted in ramayana, people have no problem Hanuman is flying like doremon or Sita is playing with kids. Ram has big fan following, but Ravana has bigger fan following; and actually nobody has problem with that. I have seen, the person leading the group of Ramlila more interested to taking the part of Ravana, but Ram (as if, please pardon me, Ram is sidekick character). But nobody has problem in that. Hinduism is such a vibrant religion, And I feel so proud to be a Hindu.Priyankarhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09060781984546413284noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-6887941423610820866.post-45125044303606419082016-05-15T11:30:36.305+05:302016-05-15T11:30:36.305+05:30Khurshi imam ji is not the Authority !! Sanskrit W...Khurshi imam ji is not the Authority !! Sanskrit Word Mamsa Has Many Meanings. Read The Real Meanings of That verses here - http://www.thespiritualscientist.com/2012/11/did-lord-rama-eat-meat/<br />Sri Rama Is Lord Himself How He Can Say/do That ? Let Haters Hate & Misinterpret it to satisry their own bad agendas. Also Ramayana is not written in 400-500BC,See the Dating of Ramayana Here - https://www.quora.com/Was-there-a-Lord-Ram-in-reality-or-is-it-just-a-myth-as-Ramayan-is-called-a-mythology/answer/Manohar-Patil-13?srid=VJ01.<br />Jay Sri Ram.Manohar Patilhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02784641747072527282noreply@blogger.com